Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Cody Passman's avatar

Hey Cam! Thanks for putting this together. The advent of digital currencies is fascinating but I still dont quite grasp how these currencies will be as transformative as crypto boosters are claiming. I think I have accepted that the block chain tech behind crypto may stick and fundamentally change our financial systems but I dont understand how the currencies, especially bitcoin are going to be the future global denomination. In other words, I can imagine central banks adopting block chain but its harder for me to understand the usurpation of fiat by a decentralized crypto whether bitcoin or other. I have a lot of questions but want to ask about two areas specifically (keep in mind that the below questions are based on my understanding, which may be completely off base):

1. Decentralization: This seems a big "pro crypto" argument in that digital currencies are decentralized with transparent chains of custody. The argument, as I understand it, is that current fiat currency is centralized and can be manipulated by a central bank, which is bad because centralizing of power can be corrupting. Crypto removes the central bank from the equation and this is a good thing because transparency reasons. A counter argument is that while there wouldnt be a central bank there would be centralized nodes of transmission (or server managers). From what I understand, when the internet was first thought of, people envisioned every individual user managing their own server. As we know, thats not what happened but instead people turned to companies that manage their servers for them, which is a consolidated market now. Here is my questions: what would prevent the server managers from consolidating their market capitalization and in effect becoming the central banks of the future?

2. Scarcity: A big pro of bitcoin specifically is that there will be a limited number ever created thus inflation really wont be a problem. However, as your sign off notes, you can buy fractions of a bit coin. Whats to prevent the infinite division of bitcoin leading to the very inflation problem that it seeks to prevent? Also, what happens if people horde bitcoin and there is not enough in circulation to create a viable market?

My current position is that crypto is too speculative and unproven to be a reliable form of currency. The current market cap gives the crypto movement some credibility in my mind but I am just not sold yet. I am open minded though and would have no problems changing my mind at some point in the future.

Thanks again for putting together the newsletter!

Expand full comment
1 more comment...

No posts